Thursday, February 13, 2014

Cutting the Cord: My Over-the-Air Antenna Setup

The following is knowledge I have acquired when I installed my rooftop antenna.  I am not recommending any particular products and I am not responsible for any damage caused as the result of your installation. I'm not an electrician nor do I have any experience with radio technology.  Everything is at your own risk!

What's the difference between an old analog antenna and a new digital antenna?  Not much.

Here is my antenna: Antennacraft HBU33 from Radio Shack.

Looks like a normal antenna, right?  It pretty much is.  The description of this antenna is High VHF-UHF antenna.  What does this mean?

Jump in the Wayback Machine to the 1980s or earlier.  TVs had two dials.  Channels 2 through 13 were on the VHF dial.  Channels 14 through 69 were on the UHF dial.  Two dials were used because kids were the remote controls of the day.  A kid has two arms.

So what is "High VHF" mean?  VHF channels were divided into upper and lower bands.  Channels 2 through 6 are lower VHF channels.  Channel 7 through 13 are upper VHF.

Since my antenna doesn't cover Lower VHF I cannot receive channels 2 through 6.

But wait a minute!  In an earlier post I said I get channel 3-1 and 3-2.  What's going on?

Digital Aliasing!
Just prior to the digital broadcast conversion, stations were broadcasting both an analog and a digital signal.  If you were watching analog channel 3, you could be sure you were watching channel 3.  If you flipped on digital channel 3-1, aren't you watching channel 3?

No.

Prior to the digital conversion, channel 3-1 was actually broadcast on channel 2!  What about channel 3-2?  Its squeezed into the channel 2 spectrum.

Once the analog broadcast ceased, channel 3 was no longer used.  (Just to confuse things, channel 3-1 and 3-2 move to channel 17 on conversion day!  Why?  Better reception on channel 17.)

Digital aliasing is handled by your TV tuner automatically.  You see channel 3-1, but the turn is receiving its signal on its true channel.

For the Cleveland area, only two stations remain on VHF.  Channel 8 broadcasts on real channel 8.  Channel 19 broadcasts on real channel 10.  Since those are both high VHF channels, I receive them.

You will need to research what sections of the spectrum you need.  I did not need low VHF channels, so I didn't spend money on an antenna that could handle those.

Antenna prices vary widely depending upon your needs.

Antenna Location
You may be tempted to place your antenna in the attic.  It may work, but the insolation, roofing material, and general house guts will cut your signal by 30% or more.  For me, I was able to get a couple dozen stations.  Good, but not great.

I decided to get a tripod mount for the roof.  My station count more than doubled!

Make sure you follow local building codes and ground it properly.  And don't do what I did.  While in the attic running cable I managed to put my foot through the ceiling in the hallway.  Now my wife is waiting for me to finish installing the new skylight!

A tripod mount is about $35.  The pole for the antenna to mount to is another $10 - $20.

Where Do I Aim?
Since every location is different, you'll have to experiment.

When aiming, keep in mind what part of your antenna should point to the most stations.  If yours resembles an arrow, you will be pointing away from those stations!

For my installation, I don't aim directly at the biggest antenna farm which is in Parma, OH.  I aim it a bit further south.  By doing that I weaken the signal from Cleveland, but increase the signal from Youngstown enough that I can watch channels from both markets.

Keep in mind the difference between analog and digital.  Analog gets "fuzzy" as the signal weakens.  Digital works perfectly until it hits a certain point.  Once you reach that point the picture simply disappears.  Experimenting is key!

Also note that weather, sun, and seasons affect your signal.  You may need to experiment over the course of a year.

Check out this site for where your stations' towers are located:

http://www.antennaweb.org/

You could get an outdoor antenna rotator.  I have not used one.  As you will see later I have four sets connected.  I want the antenna aimed the same at all times.  Also, my DVR can't control the antenna position.

Connecting to Your TV
Don't use cheap coaxial cable.  I had a bunch of RG-59 cable in my basement.  I connected that to my antenna and got NO stations.  The run from your roof to your TV set is quite a long distance.  Use RG-6 or better.

I was able to reuse RG6 cable that was purchased for my satellite system years ago.  Make sure you check for what you can reuse from your former TV provider.

Standard Definition TVs
If you are using a standard definition TV, you can still take advantage of digital over-the-air broadcasts.  TVs manufactured in 2007 or later have a digital tuner.  If not, you will need a set top converter box.

A few big box discount stores and electronic stores carry these, but supplies are getting limited.  Expect to pay about $50.

They are very easy to connect.  Simply plug in the antenna and connect the TV.

Back of a digital converter box

How is the picture?  I have used three converter boxes.  All will give you a digital picture as good as digital cable.

Connecting Multiple TVs
If you have a strong signal, simply purchase a splitter at the electronics store.  These should only cost a few bucks.

A basic splitter did not work for me.  I wanted to connect the antenna to four different TVs.  Instead, I connected an amplified splitter.  I purchased mine at a home center for $35.  Sounds expensive until you realize that your TV provider is charging $5 to $7 per extra set!

Four way signal splitter and amplifier in the wild

If you do use an amplified splitter, keep in mind that you will need access to an electrical outlet.

Coming Soon
So you just installed your antenna, but sure miss that DVR.  Next I will cover my DVR solution.  Stay tuned!




Tuesday, February 11, 2014

I Want My MeTv (What channels will you get)

What channels will I get?

I'll start right now by informing you that you won't get ESPN.  Sorry.  That's the most expensive channel on basic cable.

Major Networks
You will get the major networks.  These are HD in most markets.
  • ABC
  • CBS
  • Fox
  • NBC
  • PBS
These are the common channels you would get even back in the analog days.

Introducing Subchannels
There is a big benefit of an over-the-air (OTA) antenna, though.  The digital broadcast conversion brought us the subchannel.  Stations are no longer limited to what we would call one channel.

For example, NBC in Cleveland is on channel 3.  With the digital conversion, it shows on your TV as 3-1.  They also have a channel 3-2.  This is their weather subchannel.

Another example is channel 5 in the Cleveland market.  Channel 5-1 is the local ABC affiliate.  Channel 5-2 is the Live Well Network which broadcasts entirely different shows.

If you currently have cable you probably receive these.  If you are a satellite subscriber, these stations will be foreign to you.

Adjacent Markets
Another advantage of the OTA antenna is the ability to pick up other local markets.  At my home I pick up the Youngstown stations.  Of course they duplicate the major networks.  While it appears redundant, they do have unique programming out of prime time hours.

As an example, the Cleveland NBC station shows selected Cleveland Indians games.  If you aren't interested, but still wanted to watch NBC programming, pick the Youngstown station.  Likewise, Youngstown State games are shown on the Youngstown feed.  Sometime Fox baseball will have different games shown in Cleveland versus Youngstown.  The same goes for the NFL.

Syndicated programming can very widely.  I can watch Seinfeld on three different stations at three different times if I chose.

My Channel List in North Canton, OH
In the analog days I was able to get 2 stations with a perfect picture.

Now I get about 50 channels.

Here is the current list:
  1. 3-1: NBC HD
  2. 3-2: WKYC Weather
  3. 5-1: ABC HD
  4. 5-2: Live Well Network
  5. 8-1: Fox HD
  6. 8-2: Antenna TV
  7. 17-1 thru 17-5: TBN networks (TBN, Smile of a Child, JCTV, Enlace)
  8. 19-1: CBS HD
  9. 19-2: MeTV
  10. 21-1: NBC HD
  11. 21-2: UPN
  12. 23-1: Ion HD
  13. 23-2: Qubo
  14. 23-3: Ion Life
  15. 23-4: Shop
  16. 23-5: QVC
  17. 23-6: HSN (Home Shopping Network)
  18. 25-1: PBS (HD)
  19. 25-2: PBS Ohio
  20. 25-3: PBS World
  21. 25-4: PBS Create
  22. 25-5: Local NPR feed
  23. 27-1: CBS HD
  24. 27-2: Fox
  25. 33-1: ABC HD
  26. 33-2: UPN
  27. 33-3: Bounce
  28. 39-1: Retro TV
  29. 39-2: Tuff TV
  30. 39-3: PB&J
  31. 39-4: Christian Radio Station
  32. 43-1: UPN HD
  33. 43-2: Bounce
  34. 45-1: PBS HD
  35. 45-2: Fusion
  36. 45-3: MHz
  37. 45-4: V-Me
  38. 47-1 thru 47-5: local Christian station
  39. 49-1: PBS HD
  40. 49-2: Fusion
  41. 49-3: MHz
  42. 49-4: V-Me
  43. 55-1: UPN HD
  44. 55-2: WKBN secondary feed
  45. 55-3: This TV
  46. 61-1: Univison HD
  47. 61-3: Get-TV
My TV lists 19-1 and 19-2 twice.  Why?  Many could not receive the station very well, so they added a repeater in Akron.

What Channels Will You Get At Your House?
Use this website to determine the stations near your location.

http://www.antennaweb.org/Address.aspx

It will display a map showing where the stations are in relation to you.  It also lists stations with a color coded key to indicate signal strength.

Your mileage will vary.  Even the weakest stations I can get with a perfect picture......most of the time.

There is another factor, too.  Weather and the sun affect signal strength.  From my experience I get the worst signal strength during the summer months!

Program Variety
My channel list is heavy in subchannels.  Below is a basic description of some.

Classic reruns: Retro TV, Antenna TV, MeTV, and PB&J
Movies: Get-TV, Bounce
Home improvement and travel: PBS Create
Kids: Qubo (24/7 children's programming - mostly Canadian shows), Smile of a Child

That's All Folks!
Coming soon: choosing an antenna, connecting multiple TVs, using a DVR, and Internet streaming!

Stay tuned!

Sunday, February 9, 2014

Why I Cut the Cable TV Cord and Never Looked Back!

In January of 2010 we still had not jumped to HDTV.  We were still watching a 32 inch, 150 pound behemoth.  Most of the civilized world was now using HD.  Even the local newscasts were in HD.

The standard definition TV experience was getting worse by the month.  Many TV shows were letter boxed that rendered my 32 inch TV set into the equivalent of a 27 inch.  Weather maps were missing Toledo and Pittsburgh.  Even those obnoxious ads for credit loans were losing the phone numbers off the edge of my diminutive screen.  How would we ever get a payday loan now!

The Winter Games were starting and I had just received my tax refund.  Time to upgrade!  The pay-TV company wanted $10 more per month for the same programming in HD.  I thought the $80/mo was enough already.

I went on YouTube and found a homemade antenna design using 6 coat hangers, a piece of scrap wood, and a transformer to connect a coaxial cable.  This ugly contraption was certainly effective!  It would make MacGuyver proud!

How effective?  Our home used to have a tower antenna before it fell victim to the rust gods.  Our TV would pick up two channels.  That's it!  Two.  By 2010 most stations had added a digital signal.  I plugged in this monstrosity and picked up a couple stations from Cleveland and a couple from Youngstown.  Not only were there more stations than my analog antenna, but they were crystal clear!

With this contraption, I headed up to the attic to mount it.  I ran a coaxial cable from the attic to the TV.  To my amazement we received even more stations!  I was picking up all the major networks.  In fact I was receiving duplicate networks from both Cleveland and Youngstown markets.  Bingo!  I was on my way.

We did not upgrade to the HD package.  I figured I was saving $10 per month.  Yeah.  I'm that much of a cheapskate!  What we discovered was that we were watching the antenna 90% of the time.  The $80/mo was basically for our TV viewing for 10% of the time!

And then we received our notice from our TV provider.....

Our 2 year discount bundle was to expire next month!  Plus, as any good business would do when delivering such joyous news, our basic rate was going to increase, too!  That $80/mo for the TV service was jumping by $30 per month.  Shareholders rejoiced!  The cheapskate in me cringed!

I generally liked the TV service, so I called immediately which was two weeks prior to the bundle expiration to drop to the next lower pricing tier.  Every day I would check to see if the upper tier channels were gone.  They were not.  A few days before the expiration I called again to confirm that I would not be paying for the package I had canceled nearly two weeks prior.  The agent informed me I would not be charged.  I called daily for the next couple days.

Surprise!  Surprise!  Surprise!  I got a bill for the tier I canceled.  After arguing that I would not pay the additional tier price I asked to cancel the TV service altogether.  The agent said I could not.  Why?  He said because I have a pending order for the downgrade!  I said I would only pay for the service I wanted and used.  He informed me if I did it would be considered only a partial payment and could affect my credit rating.  I asked to speak to a manager.  He downright refused!

"You are going to drop service over a few bucks?"  It was a dare.  I don't think they expected it.

After a few days my service dropped to the lower tier so I called to drop the service.  Of course, I would have to talk to a manager just like I wanted to do earlier!  After at least 90 minutes, my service was finally canceled.

It was time to use my antenna full time!

We used my homemade antenna for several months.  During this time, we saved enough dough on TV to purchase a proper roof antenna and later a DVR.

This blog will document how I determined that cord cutting was for us.  Free TV isn't necessarily cheap.  I will inform you of some of the hazards of setting up your antenna.  I will also show you how we did it successfully!

We have gone four years without a TV bill and we have saved thousands!  You can, too!